How to Order a Butterbeer Recipe Off Starbucks Secret Menu (2024)

Muggles got you down? Learn how to order a Butterbeer recipe at Starbucks plus 6 other Harry Potter drinks on the Starbucks Secret Menu!

You’ll feel like you’re at Honeydukes in no time at all!

On a random Tuesday, we were feeling like a trip to Hogsmeade would really cheer us up! Since we couldn’t make it all the way there, we decided to do the next best thing — go to our local Starbucks!

Harry Potter fans will be delighted to know there are at least 8 secret menu recipes straight out of Diagon Alley!

All of these recipes are based on the Grande size drink (aka a medium).

The 8 Harry Potter Starbucks Secret Menu Drinks

Butterbeer Frappuccino
Gryffindor Frappuccino
Slytherin Frappuccino
Ravenclaw Frappuccino
Hufflepuff Frappuccino
Hot Butterbeer Latte
Butterbeer Iced Latte
Pumpkin Juice

While we’re not coffee drinkers, the Butterbeer Crème Frappuccino recipe at Starbucks contains no coffee and is perfect for kids, too!

Does Starbucks still have Butterbeer?

Starbucks offers a Butterbeer Frappuccino, a hot Butterbeer Latte, and an iced latte version as well. All 3 sweet treats are on the Starbucks secret menu so only witches, wizards, and house elves can order them!

How do you order from Starbucks Secret Menu?

You can order any Starbucks Secret Menu item in 3 simple steps:

Starbucks’ Butterbeer Frappuccino

Our favorite copycat recipe is theButterbeer Frappuccino! It’s available at any location and offers a slightly frozen Butterbeer treat!

How do you order a Butterbeer Frappe from Starbucks?

Ask for a Grande Vanilla Bean Frappuccino with whole milk.
Add 3 pumps of caramel syrup
Add 3 pumps of toffee nut syrup
Top with extra caramel drizzle

Substitutions

The original Starbucks Butterbeer Frappuccino recipe called for toffee syrup, but due to the pandemic – that syrup was unavailable. So the Starbucks barista suggested we add a little magic with dark caramel and brown sugar — and by golly, it worked!

You can also add pumps of cinnamon dolce syrup and a sprinkle of cinnamon on top for a cozy change.

What does Butterbeer taste like?

Butterbeer tastes like a creamy butterscotch cream soda with whipped topping on top. It’s a delicious, sweet drink.

Is the Butterbeer Frappuccino good?

Starbucks Butterbeer Frappuccino recipe is delicious! We loved how creamy and sweet it was. It’s not exactly like the Butterbeer you get at The Wizarding World of Harry Potter at Universal Studios though. It’s not better or worse – just different.

How much is a Butterbeer at Starbucks?

Our grande Starbucks’ Secret Menu Butterbeer Frappuccino was around $5.

So grab one today and then settle in with our other favorite Harry Potter movie night snacks!

Starbucks Harry Potter House Drinks

Whether you’re a Gryffindor or a Slytherin, there is a Harry Potter Inspired Starbucks drink just for you!

How do I order a Gryffindor Frappuccino?

Ask for a Grande Creme Frappuccino with whole milk.
Add 1 scoop ginger turmeric powder
Add 1 pump of the pineapple ginger syrup
Ask for strawberry puree to be in the bottom of the cup
Top with whipped cream and strawberry inclusions

This is a stock image that looks close to the real Slytherin Starbucks Drink

How do I order a Slytherin Frappuccino?

Ask for a Grande Green Tea Frappuccino with whole milk.
Ask to swap the sweetener for peppermint syrup
Add 1 scoop chocolate chips
Top with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle

Is a Frappuccino too sweet for a Slytherin? Try this! Order an iced black tea made with coconut milk and add matcha powder.

How do I order a Hufflepuff Frappuccino?

Ask for a Grande Creme Frappuccino with coconut milk.
Add 1 scoop ginger turmeric powder
Add 1 scoop chocolate chips
Add 2 pumps pineapple syrup
Top with whipped cream and mocha drizzle

Another Hufflepuff drink would be orange mango juice made with coconut milk and topped with vanilla bean powder.

How do I order a Ravenclaw Drink?

Passion iced tea made with soy milk
Add vanilla syrup

Hot Starbucks’ Butterbeer Latte

The hot Butterbeer latte is perfect forcolder weather! Here’s how to order a hot Butterbeer this Fall!

Order a Grande whole milk steamer
Add 3 pumps of caramel syrup
Add 3 pumps of toffee nut syrup
Add 3 pumps cinnamon dolce syrup
Top with Whipped cream and salted caramel crumbs

We love these Harry Potter House Tumblers on Etsy, and they’re perfect for any fan!! (Update: these specific tumblers aren’t available right now, but here’s the shop that made them!)

Starbucks Butterbeer Iced Latte

The ice latte is a great Butterbeer drink in the summer!

You can order it by asking for:

Order a Grande ice latte
Add 2 pumps of caramel syrup
Add 2 pumps of toffee nut syrup
Add 2 pumps cinnamon dolce syrup
Top with Cascara cold foam

Harry Potter Pumpkin Juice

Order a Grande apple juice
Add 1 pump of cinnamon dolce
Add 1 pump chai
Add 2 pumps of pumpkin spice

No Harry Potter beverage is quite complete without your own re-useable Harry Potter Starbucks cups though! We love Harry Potter Tumblers on Etsy! (Update: The tumblers above are no longer listed, but keep an eye on her shop for them again!)

Our next recipe to try is a white hot chocolate with butterscotch sauce! We haven’t tried it, but it sure does sound good!

We love all 8 of these Starbucks drinks inspired by the Harry Potter series!

We hope you’re able to leave the muggle world this afternoon with one of these sweet treats!